Ethical Implications of AI Explainability in Criminal Justice Systems

Dr. S. Debabrata Mukherjee, Ms. P. Rituparna Das

Abstract


Artificial Intelligence is increasingly employed within criminal justice systems to support decision-making processes such as crime prediction, risk assessment, sentencing recommendations, and parole evaluations. These systems promise efficiency, consistency, and data-driven insights; however, their growing influence over liberty and legal outcomes raises profound ethical concerns. Many AI tools used in criminal justice operate as opaque black-box models, limiting transparency and hindering accountability. Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) has emerged as a critical mechanism for addressing these ethical challenges by enabling interpretable, auditable, and contestable AI-driven decisions. This paper examines the ethical implications of AI explainability in criminal justice systems. It explores how explainability intersects with fairness, due process, accountability, and public trust, while analyzing the risks of opaque algorithms in legal contexts. The paper argues that explainability is essential not only for technical transparency but also for safeguarding fundamental rights and democratic values within AI-assisted criminal justice decision-making.

Keywords: Explainable AI, Criminal Justice, Ethical AI, Algorithmic Fairness, Legal Transparency


Full Text:

PDF 69-75

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.